“Cultural Arts Night” Part 2: Hunter College’s Undergraduate Student Government Under Fire

By: Alex Augenbraun and Shayma Ahmed

Changes: 9:00 a.m. Tuesday, added interview with USG VP

Part 1

On the night of Saturday, Nov. 14, Hunter College’s Undergraduate Student Government (USG) canceled a planned “Cultural Arts Night” event which was a collaboration of clubs, including Hunter’s chapter of Students for Justice in Palestine and Rita Levine Rabin Hunter Hillel. The cancellation and subsequent statements posted on the USG’s Instagram has brought a wave of media coverage down on Hunter’s Undergraduate Student Government.

“Your fellow student leaders are being smeared,” Ahmad Waraich, USG vice president, told The Envoy on Monday. “I hope you understand that we are real students with real jobs.”

Waraich said USG’s statements have been “purposefully vague” because student government leaders “can’t take a stance.” He called a “collab with SJP and Hillel in this political climate” a mistake and blamed it on a “lapse in communication” within USG.

When asked for further comment, Waraich said “I have to retract my statement.”

The story has drawn attention from politicians. City Council Member Eric Dinowitz, chair of the council’s Committee on Higher Education, wrote Sunday on X that the cancellation “appears to be yet another chapter in the troubling history of antisemitism at CUNY and Hunter” and that City University of New York “must immediately launch a Title VI investigation.” Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color and national origin. The USG’s statements on Instagram did not mention Hunter Hillel.

City Council Member Virginia Maloney, who represents Manhattan’s East Side, also wrote Sunday on X that “if the cancellation was rooted in a Jewish student organization’s participation, that is blatant antisemitism.” She urged the administration “to further investigate the intent behind this decision.”

Pens for Swords, a pro-Israel WhatsApp group that sends daily messages with one-click links for sending prewritten emails, has turned its attention to the USG. The group describes its mission as fighting for Israel and combating antisemitism, and says it has tens of thousands of members.

The group urged members to send a roughly 1,200-word email addressed to a vast array of public servants and CUNY administrators, including Hunter College President Nancy Cantor and US Secretary of Education Linda McMahon.

The email calls the cancellation “blatant antisemitism.” It also demands an investigation into the event’s cancellation, including the decision by the USG President Sumaiya Ahmed and Vice President Ahmad Waraich to call it off.

The email also asks the Middle States Commission on Higher Education, which accredits Hunter, to flag the cancellation as “an item for review” in the college’s next accreditation evaluation. The MSCHE is recognized by the U.S. Department of Education to evaluate the quality of over 500 institutions of higher education. The commission reviews member colleges every eight years, and Hunter began its current reaccreditation self-study in fall 2025.

Executive Director of Hunter Hillel Merav Fine Braun told The Envoy that the club is not associated with Pens for Swords.

The Pens for Swords campaign uses a tactic similar to the one-click email drive that preceded Hunter’s film and media department’s cancellation of a screening of the documentary “Israelism.”

United Jewish Appeal-Federation of New York, a Jewish philanthropic organization, said in a statement on Instagram that it is working with Hunter Hillel and the Jewish Community Relations Council of New York to “press for answers and accountability.”

Fox News’ “Outnumbered” covered the controversy on Monday in a roughly seven-minute segment. Panelist Noa Tishby, Israel’s former special envoy for combating antisemitism, said the event was canceled “because of that particular Jewish group.” Attorney Donna Rotunno questioned the USG’s safety rationale. “They say it’s about safety, and then in the next line, we’re so worried about being inclusive,” she said.

The story has also drawn international coverage. The left-leaning Israeli newspaper Haaretz and the center-right Jerusalem Post both ran stories based on the USG’s public statements.

“Cancel the event. We got the message,” Valérie Robin Clayman wrote in an opinion blog post for The Times of Israel. “It’s not so safe for Jews to dance at Hunter anymore.”

In their second statement on Instagram, the USG clarified their intentions of canceling the event were “in the interest of ensuring that USG events reflect our commitment to safety, inclusivity, and meaningful participation for all students.”

2 responses to ““Cultural Arts Night” Part 2: Hunter College’s Undergraduate Student Government Under Fire”

Leave a Reply

About The Envoy

Since 1944, The Envoy has served as Hunter College’s student-run publication, where we commit to providing fearless and accurate journalism. The Envoy covers issues related to Hunter and CUNY campuses, events and student culture.

Hunter College and Envoy Events Calender

The Envoy’s Instagram